The goaltending situation for the Edmonton Oilers has been a topic of heated debate. Throughout the last couple of seasons, they relied on a duo comprising Stuart Skinner and Calvin Pickard. The results have been mixed, prompting speculation about whether the Oilers need to make a move to upgrade in net. However, despite the swirling rumors, the team has chosen to remain steadfast with Skinner and Pickard.
Recently, the tension surrounding their goaltending situation escalated after a disheartening 6-1 loss to the Florida Panthers in Game 3 of the Stanley Cup final. This poor performance places the Oilers in a precarious position as they grapple with a 2-1 series deficit. The question arises: Should they stick with Skinner, who has had two subpar outings in a row, or give Pickard the chance to step in and potentially turn the series around?
While the debate might seem complicated on the surface, the decision should lean heavily towards continuing with Stuart Skinner as the starting goaltender. Although Cal Pickard has his supporters—especially after an initial strong showing in the first round—Skinner has earned the trust of his teammates and organization. The Oilers need stability and experience as they face their current challenges.
Critics might point to Skinner’s recent performances as reasons for concern. Allowing the first goal just 56 seconds into the game is certainly not an ideal way to start, and his subpar .783 save percentage in that game raises eyebrows. However, to place the blame squarely on his shoulders would be a disservice to all the hard work he has put in throughout this postseason.
Stuart Skinner has had several outstanding moments in the playoffs that cannot be overlooked. During the Western Conference finals against Dallas, he boasted an impressive save percentage of .966 or better in three of five games, showcasing his ability to perform when it matters most. Moreover, Skinner recorded three shutouts throughout these playoffs, demonstrating his clout as a capable starting goalie.
However, it’s essential to consider the defense that plays in front of him. The Oilers have struggled to maintain consistent defensive play, making it challenging for Skinner to shine. When the defensive unit becomes porous, it becomes nearly impossible for any goaltender to maintain a high level of performance. This isn’t just a Skinner problem; it’s a systemic issue that needs to be addressed.
If the Oilers fail to secure the Cup this season, questions regarding Skinner’s future will inevitably arise. It’s a common theme in the world of sports: when a team falls short, even the most talented players face scrutiny. With Skinner under a manageable contract of $2.6 million next season, some might speculate that General Manager Stan Bowman will seek alternative options to solidify the goaltending position. Names like John Gibson of the Anaheim Ducks may come into play as the organization evaluates its strategies for improvement.
Nevertheless, as of now, Stuart Skinner remains the best bet for the Oilers. His journey has been marked by ups and downs, yet he has shown resilience and potential. With the right support from his teammates, he can still provide the necessary performances to turn the series in favor of Edmonton.
In conclusion, while it’s easy to criticize a player after losses, Stuart Skinner has proven himself worthy of trust. The Oilers must commit to him moving forward, not only for this playoff run but also for the long haul. With Skinner in net, the team has a solid foundation on which to build, one that can potentially lead them to victory in the ongoing postseason. The organization has an opportunity to rally around their goaltender and harness this moment to emerge stronger, proving that sometimes, sticking with your guy can pay dividends in the most crucial times.
Source link
