City leaders in Tempe, Arizona, are taking significant steps to address a growing concern: the overuse of 911 by healthcare facilities. Local officials and first responders have noted a troubling trend whereby healthcare centers frequently call emergency services for medical issues that could potentially be managed within their facilities. This behavior has led to the introduction of new nuisance laws aimed at curbing this misuse and promoting better resource management.
At the beginning of this month, Tempe implemented new noise and nuisance ordinances, one of which specifically targets healthcare providers such as sober living facilities, assisted living homes, and nursing care centers. The aim is to discourage these locations from excessively relying on emergency services for routine medical situations. Vice Mayor Doreen Garlid expressed her concerns about the impact of chronic 911 calls on the city’s Fire Medical Rescue Department. She emphasized the need for healthcare facilities to employ adequate medical staff to handle emergencies internally, rather than wrestling first responders away from potentially more urgent situations.
The penalties for non-compliant facilities can be steep, starting from a $1,000 fine and escalating to as much as $4,000 based on the frequency of calls made to emergency services. Such fines intend to instigate a necessary change in how healthcare facilities manage their resources.
Cole Marvin, the executive director of Friendship Village Tempe, offers an insider perspective on the issue. While he recognizes the overwhelming number of emergency calls can indeed be daunting, his facility operates with private funding, allowing them to maintain high staffing levels and manage situations more effectively than many of their peers. Marvin pointed out that many facilities, especially those reliant on Medicaid or AHCCCS (Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System), face significant financial constraints that make adequate staffing a challenge.
This situation has been exacerbated by the ongoing impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. Staffing shortages have left some healthcare facilities unable to provide adequate support for their patients, leading to an increase in emergencies that might otherwise be manageable. For instance, Marvin illustrated a hypothetical scenario where a facility may have only a couple of staff members available for thirty patients, making it impossible for them to respond effectively to emergencies. This not only strains the healthcare system but also compromises the safety and well-being of patients.
In response to the new nuisance laws, the city plans to initially focus on education rather than punitive measures. Vice Mayor Garlid stated the city will work proactively with healthcare facilities to raise awareness about the changes before applying any fines. She emphasized the importance of fostering understanding and providing support to improve compliance instead of immediately resorting to citations. The objective is to ensure that first responders can continue to effectively manage emergencies while alleviating unnecessary demands on their services.
As the city moves forward, they remain committed to addressing the underlying challenges that contribute to the overuse of 911 by healthcare facilities. By balancing educational outreach with potential penalties for non-compliance, Tempe aims to ensure that emergency services are readily available for genuine emergencies while promoting better management practices within healthcare organizations.
In summary, Tempe’s new initiative to tackle the excessive use of 911 by healthcare facilities signals a significant shift in how local authorities are addressing resource management within the healthcare sector. By implementing nuisance laws and focusing on educational outreach, the city is attempting to create a sustainable system that respects both the needs of healthcare providers and the importance of emergency services. As this situation unfolds, it will be crucial for both the city and healthcare organizations to work collaboratively in finding solutions that prioritize patient care while ensuring efficient use of community resources.
Source link
