Real or not: Why each 2025 MLB contender can (or can’t) win it all

In the unpredictable landscape of Major League Baseball (MLB) as we approach the 2025 postseason, questions abound regarding which teams can realistically contend for the World Series title. With various leading contenders facing injuries, inconsistencies, and unexpected challenges, the upcoming playoffs promise surprises. This article evaluates the landscape, examining which teams can and cannot clinch the ultimate championship in October.

Milwaukee Brewers: Hitting Concerns

The Milwaukee Brewers have secured MLB’s best record but have struggled with power, ranking 19th in home runs while being second in runs scored. The consensus is that their reliance on small ball and manufacturing runs may be a boon during the regular season but could pose significant challenges in the postseason where home runs are crucial. Historical data shows that over the last several postseasons, teams benefiting from power have performed well. Ultimately, the prediction is that while the Brewers have a solid team, their lack of home run prowess is a genuine concern. Verdict: REAL.

Los Angeles Dodgers: Bullpen Issues

Once again, the Dodgers are navigating the turbulent waters of postseason preparations, struggling with bullpen inconsistencies that rank them 19th in the league for ERA. However, the 2024 postseason illustrated that even teams with lackluster pitching can overcome adversities with the right offensive support. In light of the Dodgers’ healthy rotation possibly returning, there is a compelling argument that they could still make a deep playoff run. Verdict: NOT REAL.

Philadelphia Phillies: A Close Look at Bulking Up

The Phillies made a bold move to acquire Jhoan Duran as their new closer, hoping to solidify their shaky bullpen issues that plagued past postseasons. With an impressive strikeout rate and a ground-ball inducing arsenal, Duran feels like the answer totheir late-game troubles. However, the absence of other key pitchers raises concerns about depth. The reliance on star offensive players, notably Trea Turner and Bryce Harper, adds pressure. If they perform under pressure, the Phillies could be a formidable contender. Verdict: REAL.

Detroit Tigers: Starters’ Woes

The Tigers are benefiting from a standout performance by Tarik Skubal, but their struggles to identify a reliable No. 2 starter are worrying. Recent champions have boasted strong second rotation pieces, while Detroit’s current options are averaging over 5.00 ERA. While the postseason format can allow teams to utilize their bullpens more, the lack of a reliable second starter is likely to hinder their progress. Verdict: NOT REAL.

Toronto Blue Jays: Bullpen Concerns

The Blue Jays have experienced their share of bullpen troubles, particularly with Jeff Hoffman bleeding runs and leading the league in home runs allowed by a reliever. Historical postseason performance has shown that a potent offense can offset bullpen deficiencies, and the Blue Jays have the capability to generate runs. If the offense can click during critical moments, they’re a team to watch. Verdict: NOT REAL.

New York Yankees: The Judge Factor

Aaron Judge’s postseason productivity has historically been inconsistent, and with lingering shoulder issues, there are legitimate concerns regarding his impact. The Yankees are heavily reliant on his performance to drive them through the postseason. Nonetheless, their surrounding lineup offers depth, and if Judge can rise to the occasion, they could have a chance at glory. Verdict: REAL.

Chicago Cubs: Lineup Strength

The Cubs feature a solid lineup with depth across nearly all positions, indicating they could thrive in the postseason’s high-pressure environment. Throughout history, teams with balanced lineups have achieved substantial playoff success. However, inconsistency among a few players raises questions about their sustainability. Verdict: REAL.

Boston Red Sox: Injuries as an Obstacle

The loss of rookie sensation Roman Anthony due to a strained oblique is a severe blow to the Red Sox. His performance has been integral to their success this year. Nevertheless, the Red Sox have a robust bullpen led by Aroldis Chapman and enough depth to weather adverse situations. While the team may face challenges, they possess the components to overcome Anthony’s absence. Verdict: NOT REAL.

New York Mets: Rookie Dependence

The Mets’ pitching rotation is unexpectedly reliant on rookies like Nolan McLean and Jonah Tong, amidst struggles from their veteran starters. Historically, teams have seen success with rookies in the postseason, but the inexperience raises significant doubts about the Mets’ ability to handle October pressure. Their offense, if firing on all cylinders, could mask the pitching uncertainties. Verdict: REAL.

San Diego Padres: Power Deficiencies

The Padres are facing serious challenges with generating power, ranking near the bottom in home runs. Even after acquisitions to bolster their lineup, their inability to consistently produce might hinder any playoff ambitions. It’s vital for star players like Machado and Tatis Jr. to step up, but doubts linger about their offensive capabilities. Verdict: REAL.

Houston Astros: Alvarez’s Impact

Despite injuries throughout the season, the Astros are navigating their challenges with the return of power-hitter Yordan Alvarez. While the offense has struggled to score runs throughout the year, Alvarez’s presence could change their dynamic significantly. If they can manage their rotation injury issues, they remain a dangerous contender. Verdict: REAL.

Seattle Mariners: Road Struggles

The Mariners are facing a significant challenge with a poor road record, which could hinder their postseason prospects greatly. Historical data reveals that recent World Series champions have maintained winning records away from home. Without significant improvements in their travel performance, their chances for a deep playoff run look bleak. Verdict: REAL.

Texas Rangers: Navigating Injuries

With Nathan Eovaldi and other key players sidelined, the Rangers face daunting hurdles. Yet, history shows that teams can still succeed despite missing aces. With Bruce Bochy’s managerial skills and potential reclamations in pitchers, they could surprise many if they make the postseason. Verdict: NOT REAL.

Kansas City Royals: Rising to the Occasion

Initially perceived as a one-man show with Bobby Witt Jr., the Royals have shown improvement and depth in their lineup recently. Since July 1, they are among the top teams in runs scored and home runs, suggesting a resurgence. If they maintain this upward trajectory, they have the potential to be wild-card threats in October. Verdict: NOT REAL.

Conclusion

As we gear up for the 2025 MLB postseason, unpredictability reigns supreme. While some teams demonstrate strengths that could carry them through October, others face crippling limitations. The balance of offensive firepower, pitching depth, and health will dictate which teams can make a legitimate run at the World Series title. With the playoffs fast approaching, only time will tell who will rise to the occasion in what’s shaping up to be a thrilling postseason.

Source link