MLB All-Star Game 2025 picks, predictions: DBacks’ Corbin Carroll, Ketel Marte starters?

The 2025 MLB All-Star Game is on the horizon, with voting currently in full swing. Amid a challenging season for the Arizona Diamondbacks, who sit at a disappointing 31-34 before their matchup with the Seattle Mariners on June 9, there is still hope for the team. Two standout players—outfielder Corbin Carroll and second baseman Ketel Marte—are generating buzz as potential starters for the National League.

As fans cast their votes for the Midsummer Classic, sports analysts and writers have begun making predictions about who deserves to take the field at Truist Park in Atlanta on July 15. Both Carroll and Marte have shown tremendous potential this season, and opinions vary on whether they will secure starting positions.

ESPN’s David Schoenfield has identified Carroll as a frontrunner for the outfield slot, praising his dynamic play and ability to change the game’s momentum. Moreover, he believes Marte deserves to start at second base, citing his impressive stats: a .294 batting average with 12 home runs in just 39 games. Notably, Marte’s ability to draw walks surpasses his strikeouts, placing him in the 90th-plus percentile for walk rate while maintaining one of the lowest strikeout rates in the league. Schoenfield suggests that Marte could stand out as one of the best players overlooked in the current season.

CBS Sports corroborated this sentiment, with Matt Snyder commenting that while Marte trails behind Cardinals second baseman Brendan Donovan in Wins Above Replacement (WAR) due to a stint on the injured list, by the time the All-Star Game arrives, he will likely have ample games played and a compelling argument to be recognized as the best second baseman in baseball. With 10 homers, six doubles, and 27 runs so far this season, Marte’s contributions to the Diamondbacks can’t be denied.

In the outfield, Carroll finds himself in a tight competition as well. Snyder highlighted Carroll as a prime candidate alongside stars like Fernando Tatis Jr. and Kyle Tucker, suggesting that the young outfielder has already established himself as a key player in the league. Despite the fierce competition, there is a growing consensus that Carroll possesses the skills and experience to stand out.

Bleacher Report weighed in on the discussion, with Joel Reuter placing Carroll firmly among his selections for outfielders while opting for Donovan over Marte at second base. The battle for the second base position appears particularly contentious, reflecting broader trends in roster selections, particularly in the National League.

Intriguingly, not everyone sees it the same way. The Athletic’s Jim Bowden placed Brendan Donovan and Brice Turang as his top choices at second base, while reviewing Carroll’s potential in the outfield behind established stars like Kyle Tucker. He acknowledged Carroll’s season thus far, highlighting his leadership among NL right fielders, evidenced by 18 home runs, a .914 OPS, and 10 stolen bases.

Despite the Diamondbacks’ struggles this season and their standing below expectations, Carroll and Marte’s performances offer a glimmer of hope for the team’s future. Their stats are impressive and tell a story of resilience amid challenges. As fans gear up for the voting period that closes on July 2, both players remain integral to the Diamondbacks’ efforts this season.

With their futures uncertain, the upcoming weeks will be crucial for Carroll and Marte as they seek to solidify their spots among the league’s elite in the All-Star Game. Voting reflects more than just current statistics; it’s about the loyalty of fans and their enthusiasm for the players who not only perform but also embody the spirit of the game.

To make your voice heard and vote for your favorite players, you can participate in the MLB All-Star Game voting online. The ballots are open until July 2, and every vote counts in determining which athletes represent their teams and the National League in this celebrated showcase of talent.

It’s an exciting time as we look toward July 15—mark the date on your calendars. Whether you’re a staunch supporter of the Diamondbacks or simply a lover of the game, the All-Star festivities promise to be a thrilling highlight of the 2025 season, showcasing talent, teamwork, and the vibrant spirit of Major League Baseball.

Source link