The 2025 Major League Baseball (MLB) regular season has sparked intense discussions among fans, analysts, and players alike as teams shuffle through the final days of competition. With several division titles and wild card spots on the line, the tension is palpable in ballparks across the nation. As we navigate through this final week, it’s crucial to reflect on the performances of all 30 teams and their respective grades for the season.
Grading Criteria Overview
Despite some teams undoubtedly excelling, it’s important to note that the absence of a "super team" this year means that no franchise stands out with an A+ rating. Instead, most teams have showcased a mix of commendable performances and glaring inconsistencies, resulting in grades ranging from A to F.
The Brew Crew: A
The Milwaukee Brewers have emerged as the standout team of the 2025 season, boasting an impressive 97 wins. Their record is highlighted by a 14-game winning streak in August that encapsulated their dominance. With a run differential of +173—attributing much of their success to a solid pitching staff and disciplined defense—the Brewers are a formidable candidate for the postseason.
Philadelphia Phillies: A-
The Phillies returned to the playoffs, firmly establishing themselves as a force in the NL East. Although they relied heavily on Kyle Schwarber’s power-hitting, their excellent rotation and solid defense, bolstered by trade deadline acquisitions like Jhoan Duran and Harrison Bader, have positioned them as favorites for the World Series.
Cleveland Guardians: B-
The Guardians have orchestrated an impressive comeback to challenge for their division title, following a mid-season slump that saw them as long shots. While their overall performance has been marked as somewhat mediocre, their ability to triumph against weaker competitors helped them develop momentum leading into October.
Detroit Tigers: C-
The Tigers’ season has been marred by a dramatic decline. After holding the best record in the league for several months, they went through a tumultuous stretch that imperiled their playoff status. Their fall from grace can be attributed to a reliance on an inconsistent roster and poor performance down the stretch.
New York Mets: C- or F?
What started as a promising season for the Mets quickly derailed. While boastful about their payroll and the star-studded roster, a late-season collapse raises concerns about leadership and decision-making, leaving fans curious about the organization’s path moving forward. If they fail to secure a wild card, an F grade will be warranted for a franchise under immense financial and fanbase pressure.
Seattle Mariners: B+
After fluctuating throughout the season, the Mariners have found their rhythm in September, winning 15 of 16 games. Their performance has lifted them into contention for the division title, driven by standout players Cal Raleigh and Julio Rodriguez and a resurgent rotation that has excelled at critical moments.
San Diego Padres: B
The Padres have secured their postseason spot primarily due to their bullpen’s performance and improvements to their offense via trades. While they have not consistently challenged for the division title, their depth and versatility could be key factors for a successful postseason run.
New York Yankees: B
Despite losing ace Gerrit Cole to an injury earlier in the year, the Yankees have remained competitive. Aaron Judge has continued to produce incredible numbers, while the pitching unit, led by Max Fried and Carlos Rodon, has risen to the occasion. However, a shaky bullpen could prove detrimental as they enter the postseason.
Boston Red Sox: C
The Red Sox have experienced a season filled with highs and lows, with several individually strong performances overshadowed by inconsistency. The Rafael Devers trade looms heavily over their season as they cling to hope for a postseason berth, making their grade precarious depending on late-season results.
Chicago Cubs: B-
The Cubs showcased an exciting first half, led by promising stars. However, injuries and performance dips soured their playoff ambitions in the second half. Whether they can establish a solid foundation for the future remains to be seen, hinging on timely performance from their roster.
Los Angeles Angels: D
After struggling to meet expectations yet again, the Angels face another losing season. Despite individual talent like Zach Neto and Jo Adell emerging, their inability to break free from mediocrity leaves fans frustrated and the organization searching for answers.
Miami Marlins: C+
Emerging from a rough previous season, the Marlins have surprised many by staying competitive despite perceived weaknesses. Their sudden offensive capabilities have drawn attention, even as pitching woes remain a significant concern.
Rockies, Nationals, and Pirates: F
These teams have faced difficult seasons punctuated by dismal performances. The Rockies are experiencing one of the worst seasons historically, while the Nationals have yet to show significant improvement. The Pirates, having taken a step backward, round out a trio of franchises in dire need of rejuvenation.
Conclusion
As the 2025 MLB season races toward its conclusion, it’s clear that teams are feeling the pressure of playoff implications. Each franchise carries its own narrative and set of expectations as they transition into the postseason. While some squads have excelled, others face difficult decisions ahead. Regardless of the outcomes, this season remains a testament to the unpredictability and excitement that MLB fans cherish, underscoring why baseball is more than just a game—it’s an ongoing story filled with twists, turns, and boundless potential.
